All articles

Best interests duty: what your client communication record needs to show

Published: 
November 20, 2026
8 Min
Updated: 
November 20, 2026
Written by
Laurent Guyot
Co-founder and CEO of Qwil Messenger, former Managing Director at Bank of America Merrill Lynch and UBS Investment Bank, writing on regulatory compliance and secure client communication in financial services.
In This Article

‍The short answer: the best interests duty asks you to act in your client's best interests when you give personal advice, and the safe harbour steps describe how. ASIC judges compliance by what's on the file. Much of the evidence it wants, from the questions you asked to the reasons a client chose one option, lives in conversations. If those conversations happen on WhatsApp, a personal phone or a lost email thread, the evidence isn't on the file.

What the best interests duty requires

The duty is in section 961B of the Corporations Act. It applies when you give personal advice to a retail client. ASIC explains how it administers the duty in Regulatory Guide 175.

The safe harbour steps

The law says you satisfy the duty if you prove you took each of the steps in section 961B(2). That word matters: the burden of proof is on you, not ASIC. In plain English, the steps are:

  1. Identify the client's objectives, financial situation and needs from what they've told you
  2. Identify the subject matter of the advice they want, and the parts of their circumstances relevant to it
  3. Where it's reasonably apparent that information is incomplete or inaccurate, make reasonable inquiries to get it right
  4. Assess whether you have the expertise to advise on that subject, and decline if you don't
  5. Where it would be reasonable to consider recommending a product, investigate the products that might meet the client's needs, and assess what you find
  6. Base all judgements on the client's relevant circumstances
  7. Take any other step that, at the time, would reasonably be regarded as in the client's best interests

The last step is the catch-all, s961B(2)(g), which the August 2026 proposal below would remove.

The related obligations

Three more obligations sit alongside the duty: the advice must be appropriate (s961G), you must warn the client if it's based on incomplete or inaccurate information (s961H), and you must prioritise the client's interests over your own when there's a conflict (s961J).

What ASIC finds when it reviews files

ASIC's February 2026 financial advice update reported on a review of 100 client files about SMSF advice. In 62 of them, the adviser couldn't show they had met the best interests duty.

The pattern is old. In its review of large advice licensees (Report 515), ASIC said it expects positive evidence on the file that the adviser met their obligations, and that amending a file after the fact to make it look compliant is undesirable (Money Management summary). Where reliable records don't exist, ASIC has said it may need to interview the licensee's clients instead (Mondaq).

The thread running through these findings is missing evidence, not missing advice. Compliance consultants who work with advisers say the same: the work was often done, but nothing on file shows it (ifa).

Where client communications fit

The ASIC record-keeping rules require you to keep the information you relied on and the action you took to satisfy each step (Brightlaw). Here's where client conversations supply that evidence.

Safe harbour step or obligation

The conversation that proves it

Identify objectives, situation and needs

The client's own words about their goals, messages updating their circumstances between meetings

Reasonable inquiries

Your follow-up questions and the client's answers, timestamped

Assess your expertise

A message referring the client elsewhere when the advice is out of scope

Base judgements on circumstances

Discussion of options the client rejected, and why

Warn if information is incomplete (s961H)

The warning itself, sent in writing, and the client's acknowledgement

Prioritise the client's interests (s961J)

Disclosure of a conflict and the client's response

A file note written after a call summarises these. A message thread is them, in the client's own words, at the time.

In Qwil, advisers can flag a message, for example as a change in circumstances or a file note, so the evidence for each step is easy to find at review time.

Common gaps in the communication record

  • Updates that arrive by text or WhatsApp. A client mentions a redundancy or a new baby in a message to your personal phone. It never reaches the file, and the next review advice doesn't reflect it.
  • Questions answered by phone with no note. The client asked about fees or risk. You answered well, but there's nothing to show it.
  • Agreements scattered across channels. The client agreed to proceed by email, sent ID by text and signed on paper.
  • Records that leave with the adviser. When an adviser changes licensee or retires, messages on a personal device go with them.

Advisers know this. A UK IFA director told Qwil that when a conversation "was on my WhatsApp or my email, it's not really recorded… if a client came back to complain". Another described a client who sent an instruction to take tax-free cash to a personal channel over Christmas, then complained when it wasn't actioned. And one wealth manager said its conversations with prospective clients run entirely on WhatsApp and email, with nothing recorded until the AML check, which is exactly where the evidence for the first safe harbour step should begin. These examples come from Qwil's analysis of 70 conversations with advice firms, mostly in the UK; none were Australian.

The fix is simple to describe: keep client conversations on a secure messaging channel built for Australian advisers, where every message, document and signature sits in one audit trail the firm owns.

What may change: the August 2026 proposal

A Treasury fact sheet updated in August 2026 proposes keeping the best interests duty and its safe harbour, but removing the broadest safe harbour step, which it calls a barrier to scaled advice (Treasury fact sheet). That's the catch-all duty to take "any other step" in the client's best interests (Allens, August 2026). It's a proposal, not yet law.

Even if it passes, the duty still rests on evidence. Removing a step changes what you must do. It doesn't change the need to prove you did it.

Checklist: is your communication record best-interests ready?

  • Client goals and circumstances are captured in writing, in the client's own words where possible
  • Updates between reviews reach the file, whatever channel they arrive on
  • Follow-up questions and answers are timestamped
  • Warnings about incomplete information are sent in writing and acknowledged
  • Conflict disclosures and client responses are on file
  • No client advice conversation lives only on a personal phone
  • Records stay with the firm when an adviser leaves, for 7 years

The simplest way to meet every point is to keep every client conversation on record in one channel your firm owns.

FAQs

Is a file note enough to prove the best interests duty? A good file note helps, but it's your summary. A contemporaneous message from the client carries more weight because it's their words at the time.

Does the best interests duty apply to general advice? No. It applies to personal advice to retail clients.

What happens if I can't show compliance? ASIC can take action against the licensee and the adviser, and the Financial Services and Credit Panel, ASIC's disciplinary body for advisers, can issue warnings or reprimands, direct training, or suspend or cancel an adviser's registration.

Will the Client Advice Record reduce what I need to keep? It's meant to shorten the advice document, not the file. See our guide to sending a Statement of Advice securely, which covers what the change means.

This guide is general information, not legal or compliance advice. Check your obligations with your licensee.

The Secure Messaging App for Australian Advisers

Keep client advice on record with messaging clients actually use.

Chat, share & sign in one place

Client data hosted in Australia

Replace email & WhatsApp

Start free trial

Similar posts

Start your 30-day free trial

Secure your client communications now.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
No credit card required
Cancel anytime